Cheerful Megalomaniac

Leaving Planet Trans? But I like it here…

Posted by: Ryan on: September 1, 2008

From my drafts folder. Originally written On July 1st

There’s an interesting discussion over at the FTM LJ community.

The Original Poster says:

The trouble is, though, that I’ve realized that “being trans” so obsessively and completely pre-transition prevented me from establishing other interests. So now, I can go anywhere and do anything I want (safely) but I don’t know what I like, or what I don’t like, or anything. And I’m almost 24 – so people kind of expect me to have all of that figured out already – since most 24 year olds do. I kind of feel like I’m rebuilding myself from the ground up, and that I have to hurry in order to catch up to everyone else.

There’s a number of commenters who had a similar experience of being ‘obsessively trans’ until, they were then able to go stealth, and I am aware of real life friends that have felt the same way after realising that they *can* choose to go stealth.

I wonder if I’ll ever hit this point?

I somehow doubt it. My transition doesn’t have a finite time frame. Its not a check list.
Haircut? Check.
Boy pants? Check.
Testosterone injections? Check.
Name change? Check.

When does it end? When I get rid of the last of the stuff that I don’t like, and was only given to me because its the ’sort of thing you give a girl’? When I have a hysto? When I have top surgery? When I pass 100%? When my birth certificate erases my female past, and has my new name and ‘corrected’ gender added to it? When most people in my life know me as ‘that guy Ryan’ instead of ‘that transguy Ryan’?

Sometimes, because the stories of intersexed boys raised as girls transitioning to male are so common I feel tempted to not correct peoples assumptions. I want to be valid, I want to be acknowledged. I want to be a person with a medical condition corrected by the wonders of modern science.
I don’t have a medical condition. I will never be ‘cured’ of my femaleness, of my queerness. I am not intersex.
The medical establishment is not a hero, rescuing me from a dire situation. It is a gaoler with keys, and locks, and chains, and secret passwords, and if I say all the right things maybe I can get past every gate, every door, maybe I can get out, see the sky, find freedom.

I don’t see an end to my transition coming. I don’t have a check list of things to do before I stop being ‘obsessively trans’. I am not obsessively trans. This is all consuming, but not the way these posters mean. My life still has room for other things, and sometimes I get all gendered out, and have to take some time, have a breather, read a book.

I don’t have a destination in mind. I will never Arrive, because I don’t want to stop traveling. I might pause along the way in a few places, but this journey is a fascinating one, rich, and full of interest. I’m not ‘looking for myself’ anymore. I am looking for wisdom, beauty, fun, love, sex, rebellion, freedom…
I’m not looking for truth.

I am searching for understanding. I want to understand all the diversity that is out there. I will not slot neatly into a male role.

5 Responses to "Leaving Planet Trans? But I like it here…"

I really like this post! You know; earlier, transsexualism was labelled as a form of intersex. And a lot of transsexuals wish very hard that they’d been intersex. I can see why, but I think it is rooted in some misconseptions. I guess most transsexuals would gain from actually speaking with an intersex person. I know I would.

I’ve been warned against being “too trans” before I am able to decide if I would like to go stealth. I’m actually offended by that. It might be a age-thing. I certainly know who I am and what I want at age 30. And I expect any other 30 year old to know too, trans or not. I find it repulsive that the gender clinic thought that I didn’t know who I was or what I wanted. I guess I’m kind of hotheaded on that issue because of how the gender clinic treated me.

I can see why transsexuals who have spent all their life trying to convince their surroundings of their right gender would feel the way you quote. I guess that is one of the few reasons I have to feel lucky, transition-wise. But it is also something that is being held against me.

I think it comes down to transsexuality being a curable medical condition or a disability.

I reallys love this part of your text:
The medical establishment is not a hero, rescuing me from a dire situation. It is a gaoler with keys, and locks, and chains, and secret passwords, and if I say all the right things maybe I can get past every gate, every door, maybe I can get out, see the sky, find freedom.

I’m only 22 and I get offended when people imply that I don’t know what I want, I am sure it must only get more frustrating at 30!
The literature is quite clear that 3 and 4 year olds know both what gender they are inside, and what sex they are percieved to be by the outside world, I am sure we know too.

I find the obsession that the medical establishment has with ‘curing’ diversity in gender and sexuality really fuckin’ creepy at times.
I don’t see my transness as a medical condition, and definitely not as a disability. Its a something else, that can be aided by medical intervention.
I’m coming around to the position that gender outlaws are able to see the world through different eyes to cissexual humanity, and that makes us special, not sick.

from my point of view the nature of journey can (as you have previously noted in your journall )change with time and life events/ecepereince.

to be a man does not mean one has to adere to typcail male aussie sterotypes. I belive one can still be a massculine man without the aussie bloke role model.

In my experience its even pretty nice to get gentleman and sir.

I see transsexualism as a disability regarding my body not functioning as a male body usually do. It’s not possible to cure transsexualim in my case; I’m old enough to have a past life that I don’t want to forget, and my body will never be a normal male body.
I think that all disabilities have something to teach the abled (is that correct spelling?). Ergo: Special – not sick.

I feel vaguely squicked out by trans people using disability culture talk to describe transsexuality, but that is only because many of them are clueless and unknowingly railroading disability activist causes. However, if that is how people choose to define themselves, then I’m not about to complain.

For myself though, I really don’t like to identify as a disabled person. Totally agree with you re: the special not sick assessment though. I am developing a true fascination for disability culture and especially aspergers and autism. I’m not sure what I want to study more, the connection between transness and autism, or the cultural differences between trans women and trans men!

Leave a Reply

Blog Stats

  • 25,405 minions and rising!